The Viral Costco Pie: Inside the Social Media Phenomenon Driving Kitchen Creativity

A user-generated cooking method for a popular warehouse club dessert has exploded across social media platforms, creating a significant cultural moment that underscores the influence of online communities on consumer behavior and retail sales. This viral Costco pie trend involves a second baking process that users claim dramatically enhances the texture and flavor of the store-bought item. A seemingly simple culinary adjustment to a mass-produced dessert has become a major topic of online conversation, demonstrating the potent, often unpredictable, influence of social media on consumer trends. The subject of this fascination is a pie from Costco Wholesale Corporation, which consumers are “hacking” by baking it a second time with additional ingredients to achieve what many describe as a superior, near-gourmet result.

The phenomenon, widely dubbed the “twice-baked” viral Costco pie, has gained significant traction on platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and Reddit. The process typically involves taking a pre-baked Kirkland Signature pie often the popular pumpkin or apple varieties adding toppings like a crumble or a glaze and baking it again. Proponents claim this second bake crisps the crust and deepens the filling’s flavor, elevating a standard grocery item into a noteworthy dessert. “This is a classic example of modern ‘remix culture’ applied to food,” said Dr. Angela Frame, a digital media sociologist at the University of Washington who studies online trends. “Consumers are no longer passive recipients; they are active co-creators. They take a mass-market product and personalize it, then share that innovation with a global community, creating a feedback loop that can drive real-world sales.”

Analyzing the Social Media Food Trend

The trend appears to have originated from various user posts in late 2024 and has since snowballed. On TikTok, the hashtag #CostcoPieHack has amassed millions of views, with countless videos showcasing different variations of the technique. These short-form videos often feature dramatic before-and-after shots, user taste tests, and step-by-step instructions, making the hack easily replicable for a wide audience. This event follows a pattern of social media food trends that have previously captured public attention, such as the Dalgona coffee craze of 2020 or the viral baked feta pasta of 2021. According to a report from Datassential, a food and beverage insights firm, trends originating on platforms like TikTok can influence grocery purchasing decisions for more than 40% of Gen Z and Millennial consumers.

“What makes these trends so powerful is their perceived authenticity,” explained retail analyst David Bishop, a partner at Brick Meets Click. “This isn’t an official marketing campaign from Costco. It’s an organic, word-of-mouth endorsement that consumers trust far more than traditional advertising. For a retail grocery giant, this kind of user-generated buzz is invaluable.”

Impact on Retail and Corporate Response

While Costco has not released official sales data directly linked to the trend, anecdotal reports from shoppers on social media indicate increased demand for their pies, with some locations reportedly selling out during peak periods. The company, known for its limited public relations engagement, has not issued a formal statement on the viral phenomenon, a strategy consistent with its brand ethos of relying on product value and member loyalty.

The trend highlights a core component of Costco’s business model: the cult-like following of its private-label Kirkland Signature brand. By offering high-quality products at competitive prices, the company fosters a loyal customer base that actively shares “finds” and “hacks,” effectively creating a community of brand ambassadors.

Experts suggest that such organic trends can pose a minor challenge for supply chain management but are overwhelmingly beneficial. “The earned media value from a trend like this can be in the millions of dollars,” noted Frame. “It reinforces Costco’s image as a source for quality ‘blanks’ that consumers can customize, keeping the brand relevant in a digital-first era.” The “twice-baked” pie is more than just a dessert; it’s a case study in modern commerce, where the line between producer and consumer is increasingly blurred. As social media continues to shape public tastes, the next viral sensation may be waiting in the aisles of any local supermarket, ready for its close-up.

From Ice Cream to Tiramisu, These Are the Top-Rated Costco Frozen Desserts