Sam’s Club has introduced a new bakery item, Member’s Mark Cake Pops, which are rapidly gaining popularity among shoppers, with some influential fans rating them a perfect “10/10.” The new product, available in two flavors, enters a competitive market for convenient sweets and draws immediate comparisons to similar, higher-priced offerings from the coffeehouse chain Starbucks. This launch leverages the warehouse club’s reputation for successful and often viral bakery items.

Member’s Mark Cake Pops

Key Fact	Detail / Statistic
Product	Member’s Mark Birthday Cake & Cookies ‘N Creme Cake Pops
Price	$18.98 for a 14-count package (approx. $1.36 per pop)
Fan Reception	Rated “10/10” by social media food reviewers
Key Competitor	Starbucks Cake Pops (approx. $3.25 per pop)

A Sweet Debut with Perfect Scores

The new bakery additions, sold in a 14-count combination pack, feature two distinct flavors designed to appeal to a broad audience: Birthday Cake and Cookies ‘N Creme. The Birthday Cake pop consists of a sweet vanilla cake interior, coated in a white chocolate drizzle and topped with rainbow sprinkles. The Cookies ‘N Creme version offers a moist, fudgy chocolate cake center with a coating that includes cookie crumbs for added texture.

The product quickly captured the attention of social media influencers and bargain-hunting shoppers. The Instagram account @samsclubfoodreviews, which tracks new and popular items at the warehouse, shared a glowing review shortly after the product’s release. The reviewer praised the texture, describing both cake pops as “spot on,” noting they were “dense, chewy, and soft in the center.” The account gave both flavors a “10/10” rating, concluding they are “fun, flavorful, and definitely worth picking up before they disappear from the bakery.”

This enthusiastic reception highlights a key aspect of Sam’s Club’s strategy: creating private-label products that rival or exceed the quality of well-known national brands at a significantly lower cost. A 14-pack of the Member’s Mark Cake Pops retails for $18.98, making the individual cost approximately $1.36. This price point stands in stark contrast to Starbucks’ popular cake pops, which typically sell for around $3.25 each. For a bulk purchase, this represents a substantial savings for consumers.

Building on a History of Bakery Success

The excitement over the new cake pops is not an isolated event but rather the latest chapter in the success of the Sam’s Club bakery department. The retailer has a long history of producing beloved baked goods under its Member’s Mark brand that cultivate a loyal following.

Perhaps the most notable example is the Member’s Mark Tuxedo Bar Cake. This dessert, a long-standing fixture in the refrigerated bakery section, has achieved a near-cult status among club members. The 39-ounce cake features layers of rich chocolate cake, creamy chocolate mousse, and a smooth white chocolate-cream cheese filling, all covered in a dark chocolate ganache.

The Tuxedo Bar Cake’s enduring popularity is evident in the thousands of positive reviews on the Sam’s Club website. With over 4,500 reviews, the cake maintains an average rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars. Customers frequently describe it as “decadent,” “bakery-quality,” and an “incredible value” at its typical price of $16.98. One recent 5-star review noted, “This cake is a chocolate lover’s dream come true… It strikes the perfect balance between sweet and indulgent without being overwhelming.”

The widespread acclaim for the Tuxedo Bar Cake has led Sam’s Club to leverage its popularity in other areas of the store. In early 2024, the company held a vote for members to choose a new food court dessert. The winner was the Tuxedo Sundae, a limited-time offering made with vanilla ice cream, caramel syrup, and chunks of the famous bar cake. This move demonstrates the company’s awareness of its most popular products and its strategy of extending those successes into new formats.

The “Member’s Mark” Strategy

The successful launch of the cake pops and the sustained popularity of staples like the Tuxedo Bar Cake underscore the growing strength of private-label brands. Sam’s Club, through its Member’s Mark line, focuses on developing products that offer premium attributes—from ingredient quality to taste—at a value-oriented price point.

According to information on the Sam’s Club website, the Member’s Mark brand aims to provide high-quality items, some featuring organic and fair-trade ingredients. The bakery’s ability to consistently produce items that generate significant online buzz and high praise from customers is a testament to this strategy’s effectiveness.

As many of the warehouse club’s most popular bakery items are seasonal or available for a limited time, the positive initial response to the Member’s Mark Cake Pops suggests they may become another sought-after treat. Shoppers interested in trying the new dessert may need to act quickly, as the “10/10” reviews and favorable price comparison are likely to drive high demand across the country.

Starbucks Unleashes Limited-Time “Firework Frappuccino” with Popping Pearls